This unfortunate case is the latest ‘good’ example of the interface between human research ethics and research integrity; where a failure to obtain ethical clearance can result in the forcible retraction of a paper (and quite possibly research misconduct proceedings). As noted previously such a forced retraction can have serious and very long-lasting impacts on the careers of ALL members of a research team.
.
One of the students included in the paper thought so, and complained to the journal after learning that it had published the case study of the program without the approval required for studying people. The authors admitted they didn’t get consent from participants, because they didn’t realize the work required it. The mix-up has prompted both them and the journal to reconsider their policies regarding ethics approval of studies.
.
In the meantime, “A Project-Based Case Study of Data Science Education” has been retracted, with this notice:
.
“It has come to the attention of the Data Science Journal Editors that the authors of the paper “A Project-Based Case Study of Data Science Education” (Turek, Suen and Clark, 2016) did not seek the necessary approval for research involving human subjects prior to conducting their study. In addition, they failed to obtain consent from research participants before publication. The article has therefore been retracted. In the interests of protecting the identity of the research participants, we have also withdrawn the contents of the article from the published record.
.
Data Science Journal requires that all research involving human subjects is conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki (or equivalent framework) and, if appropriate, has been approved by the local institutional research ethics committee.
Does your work need IRB approval? Better check, says author of retracted paper – Retraction Watch (Shannon Palus: September 2016)
Posted by saviorteam in Research Integrity on November 4, 2016
Keywords: Breaches, Controversy/Scandal, Ethical review, Human research ethics, News, Research integrity, Research Misconduct, Researcher responsibilities
Keywords: Breaches, Controversy/Scandal, Ethical review, Human research ethics, News, Research integrity, Research Misconduct, Researcher responsibilities
Related Reading
No Related Readings Found!
Related Links

Random selected image from the AHRECS library. These were all purchased from iStockPhoto. These are images we use in our workshops and Dr Allen used in the GUREM.